Skip to content
B Benno's Refinishing

Hardwood Floor Refinishing

A good hardwood floor is worth saving. Most worn floors do not need replacing — they need sanding back to clean wood and a fresh finish, done properly. Here is how the work goes, and how to tell whether your floor needs a full refinish or just a fresh coat.

Refinished hardwood floors by Benno's Refinishing

The full process, step by step

A full refinish sands the floor back to bare wood and rebuilds the finish from there. How long a job takes depends on the size of the area, the condition of the floor, and whether stain is involved. Timelines vary by project — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing.

  1. Estimate and walkthrough. We look at the floor together, check how worn the finish is and how much wood is left to work with, and settle the question that matters most: does this floor need a full refinish, or would a buff and coat do it? Stain and sheen samples go on your actual floor before anything is decided.
  2. Clear the room. Furniture and rugs come out, closets get emptied, and pictures come off the walls — sanding vibrates the whole room. Doorways to the rest of the house are sealed off with plastic to keep dust where it belongs.
  3. Sand, coarse to fine. The old finish comes off in passes through progressively finer grits, with an edger along the walls and hand work in the corners. The floor is vacuumed and wiped down between passes so each grit erases the scratches of the last.
  4. Repairs. Gaps, cracks, and nail holes are filled. A damaged board or two can usually be cut out and woven in with matching wood, then sanded flat with the rest of the floor. Squeaky spots are best fixed now, while the floor is bare and accessible.
  5. Stain, if you want it. Once the floor is bare wood it will take just about any stain, light to dark. Stain needs to dry before the finish coats go on — darker stains take longer. A floor that is staying its natural color skips this step entirely.
  6. Finish coats. Three coats is the usual number for a floor, sometimes two for a thicker oil-based finish. Each coat is lightly buffed and cleaned before the next goes on. Then the finish needs its drying time, and we walk the floor together before calling it done.

Connected rooms with wood running straight through should be done at the same time — it is the only way the color and sheen match perfectly. A doorway with a threshold makes a natural break point if the work has to be phased.

Full refinish vs. buff & coat

These are two different jobs, and picking the right one starts with an honest look at the floor. A buff and coat — also called a screen and recoat — lightly abrades just the top layer of finish and adds one fresh topcoat. It never touches bare wood. It is the right call when the finish is dull or lightly scuffed but still intact. Timelines vary by project — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing.

A full refinish is the answer when the damage goes deeper than the finish: worn-through traffic lanes, dark scratches you can feel with a fingernail, grey patches where bare wood has oxidized, water soaking in instead of beading, or a color change. A recoat cannot fix any of those — only sanding back to bare wood can.

Two quick checks contractors use: put a drop of water on a worn spot. If it beads and sits, the finish is intact and a recoat will likely do. If it soaks in and darkens the wood, the finish has worn through. And run a fingernail across a scratch — if you cannot feel it, it is in the finish; if your nail catches, it is in the wood.

A floor benefits from a buff and coat on a planned cycle, and a full refinish when the finish has worn through, depending on traffic. The important thing is to recoat before the finish wears through to bare wood. Once bare oak is exposed it greys, and the longer it is left, the more sanding it takes to bring back.

Oil-based vs. water-based finish

The finish choice comes down to look and smell. There is no single right answer — it depends on the wood, the color, and how you live in the house.

Oil-based finish gives the classic warm look: an amber tone that deepens over time. It usually goes on in 2 to 3 coats, levels itself nicely, and is forgiving to apply. The trade-off is smell: it smells strong while it dries and hardens. Timelines vary by project — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing. It suits red oak and traditional, warmer woods, where that amber glow is the whole point.

Water-based finish dries clear and stays clear — the color you see on day one is the color years later. It goes on in 3 to 4 coats, and the odor is low enough that most households stay in the home while the work is going on. Timelines vary by project — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing. It is the usual choice for white oak, maple, and grey or whitewashed looks, where ambering would spoil the color. Modern commercial-grade water-based finishes have closed the old durability gap — they are built for heavy foot traffic.

One thing to know: a water-based finish over a grey or whitewashed stain is not just a preference, it is close to a requirement — an oil-based finish will turn that floor yellow. And whichever finish is on the floor now, the recoat should match it; the two types do not always bond to each other.

How the finish hardens

A floor can be walked on before the finish is fully hard, and the two finishes differ in how they dry and harden. The specifics of timing for a given job come from Kate — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing.

Property Water-based finish Oil-based finish
Color and ambering Dries clear and stays clear Warm amber tone that deepens over time
Odor Low odor Strong smell while it dries
Number of coats Usually 3 to 4 coats Usually 2 to 3 coats
Durability and application Modern commercial-grade formulas are built for heavy foot traffic Levels itself nicely and is forgiving to apply
Which woods they suit White oak, maple, and grey or whitewashed looks Red oak and traditional, warmer woods

A buff and coat is simpler than a full refinish. Having the work done before a move-in, or while the rooms are empty, is the easiest version of this job — the rooms are empty, the finish dries undisturbed, and you come home to finished floors. Timelines vary by project — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing.

When to refinish, when to recoat, when to replace

Refinish when the finish is worn through in the traffic lanes, the color has gone grey or faded in the sun, or you want a different color. Recoat when the floor just looks tired — dull, hazy, lightly scratched — but the finish is still doing its job. Replace is rarely the answer for a solid wood floor: most solid floors can be sanded several times over their life, typically 4 to 10 sandings depending on how thick the wood is above the tongue. Each sanding takes off only a thin slice.

Engineered floors are a different story — it depends entirely on the thickness of the wear layer. With a wear layer under about 2 mm there is generally nothing to sand, and refinishing is not an option. That is something we check at the estimate, at a vent or a threshold, before promising anything.

A few things do point toward repair or replacement of boards rather than a straight refinish: nail heads starting to show at the surface, which means past sandings have taken the floor close to its fasteners; black pet stains or water damage that goes through the full thickness of a board; and a spongy or moving floor, which usually means trouble in the subfloor that has to be dealt with first. A handful of stained boards near a door is no reason to replace a whole floor — those boards get woven in and the floor is sanded as one.

Stain, color, and sheen

Color change only happens with a full sand — a recoat keeps the color you have. Once the floor is bare, it will take just about any stain, and the same stain reads differently on different wood: warmer and more golden on red oak, cooler and more muted on white oak. Maple and pine take stain unevenly and usually need a conditioner first, or the result comes out blotchy. Dark floors show dust and every dent more than light ones; that is worth knowing before choosing a near-black stain.

Sheen is the other decision, and it is mostly about how much wear you want to see. Satin is the most common choice — enough life to read as cared-for, muted enough to hide dust and fine scratches. Matte is the forgiving modern pick and hides marks best. Semi-gloss and gloss look stunning on day one and show everything after that. Sheen does not change how hard the finish is; a matte and a gloss from the same finish, applied the same way, hold up to daily wear the same — matte just makes the marks harder to spot.

Homeowner prep

Before we arrive, it helps to have the rooms ready:

  • Move furniture, rugs, and anything on the floor out of the rooms being done. Plan where it goes — a garage or a room that is not being worked on.
  • Empty closet floors and take pictures, mirrors, and anything hanging on shared walls down. Sanding vibrates the room.
  • Clear a path from the driveway to the work area, and make sure we have power and water access.
  • Keep the heat on at its normal setting. A stable temperature and humidity help the finish dry and cure the way it should.
  • Keep pets and kids out of the work area while sanding and finishing are going on.
  • Small and fragile items, electronics, and valuables are yours to move — we handle the heavy furniture as part of the job, and we will say so plainly at the estimate if something needs a professional mover.

Dust, odor, and staying in the house

Sanding is dusty work, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something. Dust containment — sanders hooked to filtered vacuums — captures most of it at the source, and plastic at the doorways keeps the rest out of the rest of the house. It does not mean zero dust, and a final cleaning by the homeowner is still part of the job. If anyone in the house has asthma or breathing trouble, say so at the estimate so we can plan around it.

Staying in the house is realistic with a water-based finish, as long as the bedrooms and a bathroom sit outside the work zone. With an oil-based finish, most households plan to be elsewhere while the fumes are strongest. The rooms being finished are off-limits while coats are drying either way — no shoes, no bare feet, socks only once the finish allows it.

Aftercare

Once the finish has cured, keeping it looking good is mostly a matter of not working against it:

  • Sweep or dust regularly — grit underfoot is what wears a finish down. Clean with a pH-neutral hardwood cleaner and a barely damp mop.
  • Skip the steam mop, the vinegar and water, wax, and acrylic shine products. They dull the finish, leave residue, or can keep a future recoat from bonding.
  • Felt pads under every furniture leg, and lift heavy pieces instead of sliding them.
  • Clean up spills right away. Polyurethane makes wood water-resistant, not waterproof.
  • Use rugs and mats in the high-traffic spots, and rotate them now and then so the sun does not leave pale patches where they sat. Wait until the finish is fully cured before rugs go down.
  • Plan on a buff and coat on a regular cycle. Timelines vary by project — call Kate at 312-493-6151 to discuss timing. Done on schedule, it keeps a wood floor out of the replacement cycle for a very long time.

Where we do this work

Hardwood floor refinishing is our core work, and we do it across Southwest Michigan — South Haven, Saugatuck, St. Joseph, Holland, Kalamazoo, and the towns around them. A few nearby pages:

Also see Hardwood Floor Refinishing and Hardwood Floor Buff & Coat in our services, and the residential refinishing and commercial refinishing pages for how the work differs between homes and businesses.

Call for an estimate

Talk to Kate about your floors — whether they need a full refinish or just a fresh coat, we will look together and give you a straight answer.